IPI welcomes repeal of criminal libel in Grenada, pushes other countries to follow suit

26.10.2012 · 1752 views

National Committee working to decriminalise defamation in Azerbaijan<br /> <br /> By: IPI Azerbaijan National Committee<br /> <br /> BAKU, Oct 25, 2012 – The International Press Institute (IPI) recently announced that Grenada has become the first independent state in the Caribbean to decriminalise defamation, a welcome development given that IPI has decided to focus on the decriminalisation of defamation in countries where it is still used as a means to persecute journalists. <br /> <br /> <br />

According to Grenada’s Ministry of Legal Affairs, a July reform to the country’s criminal code included the repeal of Section 252, which regulated “negligent” and “intentional” libel and provided for prison terms of up to six months and two years, respectively. The recent reform also repealed Section 253, which established the circumstances under which criminal defamation could be committed.

IPI has intensified its efforts to end criminal defamation since the beginning of the year, pushing for change in repressive laws affecting media freedom in many Caribbean states. On this, IPI is working with its partner in the region, the Association of Caribbean MediaWorkers (ACM). In public statements and letters to political leaders, IPI has strongly urged regional governments to decriminalise libel offences.

Grenada Attorney General Rohan A. Phillip explained to IPI in a telephone conversation that the abolition of criminal libel “helps to keep democracy alive and keep those who hold the reins of power in check.” He added: “This government, even in opposition, felt, as a wide percentage of the world does, that having criminal libel on the books is a formal hindrance to freedom of expression and of the press. We were of the view that civil responsibilities and forms of redress are adequate.”

IPI Executive Director Alison Bethel McKenzie has made several trips to the region in recent years, meeting with government officials and media in other to push these changes through. Bethel McKenzie, expressing her delight at the news from Grenada, said: “I want to thank Prime Minister Tillman Thomas for following through on his stated intention to abolish criminal defamation before the end of the year.” IPI has also expressed hopes that other governments such as Jamaica, the Dominican Republic, Barbados and Trinidad and Tobago – which have shown interest in decriminalising defamation – will speed up the process. At IPI’s 2012 World Congress in Trinidad and Tobago, IPI members approved the “Declaration of Port of Spain,” which calls on Caribbean governments to repeal criminal defamation legislation in support of strong, free, and independent media. Also at the Congress, Trinidad and Tobago Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar pledged to bring the island nation’s criminal defamation laws in line with international standards.

The new development from Grenada has set a precedent and it is hoped that not only Caribbean countries, but also others around that world that still have similar repressive laws, will follow suit. In Azerbaijan, a progressive effort by the government of President Ilham Aliyev to repeal the defamation law is currently underway. IPI has been working with its Azerbaijan National Committee and other partners to see that this change is achieved. IPI Executive Director Alison Bethel McKenzie was recently in Baku for the IPI Oil, Gas and Media conference, and in one of her meetings with the head of the presidential department dealing with political and public issues, Ali Hasanov, she urged the government to work with legislators to consider a draft law repealing defamation that is currently before parliament and to quickly pass the proposal.

Bethel McKenzie said: “During our visit to Baku, we welcomed the commitment expressed by Presidential Adviser Dr. Ali Hasanov to repeal criminal defamation laws in Azerbaijan by the end of 2012. IPI has long campaigned for a complete decriminalisation of defamation as an important element of press freedom. Criminalising defamation is unnecessary and serves only to chill investigative reporting, to protect public officials and certain businessmen from necessary scrutiny and to deny the basic human right of freedom of expression.

“We hope soon to be able to congratulate Azerbaijan’s government on taking this important, necessary step. We also urge the government to use changes in criminal defamation law as an opportunity to bring civil defamation law in line with international standards as well as the recommendations expressed by the European Court of Human Rights and the OSCE. These include drawing clear distinctions between statements of fact and value judgments; making available the defences of truth, public interest and reasonable publication; and ensuring respect for the need for proportionality between the sanctions imposed and the injury to reputation suffered.”

(c) 2018. IEPF